The optimists promise a world where labour is optional and income is universal. Suppose they are right. The oldest questions about work would then become urgent.
Suppose the forecasts come true. Suppose that within a generation machines can make, carry, build and calculate everything a society needs, and that the wealth they produce is shared widely enough for nobody to go hungry. The fear of losing one’s job would fade. What would replace it?
The question sounds like a luxury. It is in fact an old and serious one, and thinking about it now is the best way to judge the future being sold to us.
An old prediction
In 1930 the economist John Maynard Keynes wrote an essay for his grandchildren’s generation. He predicted that within a hundred years, growth and technology would solve what he called the economic problem, and that people would work perhaps fifteen hours a week. The challenge, he thought, would then be how to use freedom wisely.
He was right about the wealth. Rich countries are several times richer than they were in 1930. He was wrong about the hours. People went on working, partly because wants grew as fast as output, and partly because the gains were not shared in the way he imagined.
That history is a warning for today’s prophets. Abundance does not automatically become leisure. Who owns the machines, and how their product is divided, decides whether plenty frees people or merely makes some of them redundant.
The question of income
Elon Musk, the best-known advocate of a workless future, speaks of universal high income. In his account, robots and AI will produce so much that everyone can have what they want. He has suggested the money would come as payments from government.
Even sympathetic observers see the gap in this. The robots will belong to someone. For their output to reach everyone, the owners must be taxed, or must share voluntarily, or ownership itself must be spread. None of these happens by itself. The investor Michael Burry, responding to Musk, predicted revolution first.
For a country like India the difficulty is sharper. If the machines and the companies that own them are foreign, the wealth they generate will accumulate abroad. A universal income needs a source. A nation that only imports robots may find it has lost the wages without gaining the profits.
The question of dignity
Income is not the whole of what work provides. A job gives a person a place among others, a reason to be expected somewhere, a claim to have contributed. Societies everywhere tie respect to usefulness.
The hedge-fund founder Ray Dalio has put the worry bluntly: uselessness and money may not be a good combination. Studies of long-term unemployment bear him out. People who lose work suffer in health and spirit even when their income is protected. A cheque does not confer a role. That is the weakness of treating income as the whole answer.
The philosopher Hannah Arendt saw this coming in the 1950s. She warned of the prospect of a society of labourers without labour, deprived of the one activity around which they had organised their lives. Modern societies, she argued, had come to define human beings by their jobs. Take the jobs away and nothing has been prepared to take their place.
The question of meaning
Musk himself has raised the deepest form of the problem. If computers and robots can do everything better than you, he asked, does your life have meaning?
There are grounds for a hopeful answer. Much of what people value most has never been paid work: raising children, caring for parents, friendship, worship, music, sport, learning for its own sake. Nobody stops playing chess because a computer plays it better, or stops running because a car is faster. An activity can matter to the person doing it even when a machine could do it more efficiently.
India’s own traditions offer resources here. Gandhi distrusted machinery not because it was modern but because he feared it would leave hands idle and concentrate power; he valued work, such as spinning, that kept people skilled and self-reliant. One need not share his remedy to take his point. A good society is measured by what its people are able to do and to be, not only by what they are able to consume.
What should not be handed over
This suggests a distinction the enthusiasts tend to skip. Some work is a burden that people would gladly give up: cleaning sewers, breathing furnace fumes, carrying loads that ruin the body. Machines that take it are a liberation.
Other work is a human good in itself. Teaching a child, nursing the sick, making something with skill, serving a community: these are not just outputs to be produced at lowest cost. A robot might do some of them. Whether it should is a different question, and not one for engineers alone.
The real choice ahead is therefore not between work and no work. It is about which tasks to automate and which to keep, and about who decides. Left to the market, the answer will be whatever is cheapest. A wiser society would ask what it wants its people to spend their lives doing.
Before the machines arrive
None of this is urgent in the way the viral videos suggest. Humanoid robots today do a handful of simple tasks in a few factories, usually with people watching over them. The workless world is a forecast, and the forecasters have something to sell.
But the direction is plausible, and the questions take longer to answer than the technology takes to arrive. How should the gains be shared? How do people keep their standing when their labour is not needed? What do we teach the young, if not how to earn a living?
Keynes thought the hardest task would be learning to live well once necessity was removed. Nearly a century later that remains the unfinished part of his prediction. The machines may be coming to relieve us of toil. They cannot tell us what to do with the gift.



