COP31 entered its closing phase on Wednesday with 21 issues unresolved, one finance text entirely bracketed, and a draft cover decision containing two consecutive paragraphs that say different things about fossil fuels — one urging faster action on the Dubai commitment to “transition away”, the next calling for an accelerated “phase out”. India used its national statement to insist that equitable access to the remaining carbon budget is “non-negotiable” and to resist any obligatory reading of the Global Stocktake. Revised texts were due on Thursday; the summit is scheduled to close on Friday and is widely expected to overrun.
The final two days of a climate conference are when the drafting becomes the diplomacy. At Antalya on Wednesday, the Turkish presidency and its Australian co-presidency were holding a text with 21 open issues and one finance paragraph wholly in brackets, meaning no part of it is agreed.
The contradiction at the centre
The first draft cover decision, released on Monday 16 November, carries two consecutive paragraphs on fossil fuels that pull in different directions. One urges accelerated action on the commitment made at COP28 in Dubai to “transition away” from fossil fuels. The next calls for an accelerated “phase out”.
The distinction is not semantic. “Transition away” was the carefully negotiated Dubai formula, acceptable to producer states because it describes a direction without a terminus. “Phase out” implies an end point. Keeping both in the final text is unlikely; which one survives will be read as the summit’s verdict on whether the Dubai language was a floor or a ceiling. Either paragraph could be struck.
What else is contested
- Electrification. The presidency’s “35×35” proposal would raise electricity’s share of global final energy consumption from about 23 per cent to 35 per cent by 2035. Seventy-five countries back it, with the European Union signing on 17 November and pressing for explicit “clean power” wording. India declined the pledge; the reasoning has not been officially stated.
- Adaptation finance. The draft proposes a collective goal of at least US$120 billion, building on COP30’s call to at least triple adaptation finance by 2035. No baseline for “triple” is agreed. UNEP has put the actual need at roughly US$305 billion a year, so the proposed goal covers something between a fifth and a third of it. The EU is resisting a new financial commitment.
- The IPCC timetable. The draft sets a 2028 deadline so that the next Intergovernmental Panel reports can inform the second Global Stocktake, which formally began at this conference and concludes in 2028. Russia, Saudi Arabia and China say the schedule is too compressed; India and others have sought 2029. IPCC chair Jim Skea has said the forthcoming Working Group II report “will address adaptation finance for the first time”.
India’s position
Environment Minister Bhupender Yadav delivered India’s national statement — a short intervention of about 400 words, as reported by Down To Earth — built around equity and delivery rather than ambition.
“Equitable access to the remaining, depleted, carbon budget is non-negotiable,” he said. On finance: “The developed world must honestly and expeditiously discharge their climate-finance obligations.”
India’s asks, as reported, were: equity, climate justice and common but differentiated responsibilities; development space for developing countries; a Global Stocktake that remains informational rather than obligatory; a Just Transition Mechanism grounded in equity; and no unilateral trade measures — which Down To Earth ties to the EU’s carbon border adjustment mechanism, though one account notes CBAM was not named. India stated that its next nationally determined contribution is aligned with the Viksit Bharat 2047 framework.
The arithmetic behind the carbon-budget argument is the part worth explaining, because it is the hinge of India’s whole negotiating posture. India has roughly 17 per cent of the world’s population and accounts for something in the region of 4 to 5 per cent of cumulative historical emissions. The remaining budget consistent with limiting warming to 1.5°C is finite and small. If that remainder is allocated by current emissions or by a uniform percentage cut, countries that have emitted least historically absorb the tightest constraint on future energy use. If it is allocated with reference to historical responsibility or to population, the distribution reverses. Every dispute at Antalya over the words “transition away”, over a 35 per cent electrification target and over who pays for adaptation is, underneath, a dispute about that allocation. India has raised historical responsibility at COP27, COP29 and COP30, and did so again here.
Sentiment in the hall
The public mood from vulnerable states and from civil society was impatient. “Resilience has a limit. And beyond that limit is survival,” said Feleti Teo, Prime Minister of Tuvalu. The Marshall Islands, speaking for the small island states, pressed for a faster transition and warned against weakening the Dubai commitment; Vanuatu wants the fossil-fuel roadmap prominent in the mitigation section.
Producer and developing-country positions diverged. Tanzania, South Africa and Iran stressed that any transition must be nationally determined or voluntary, with Iran warning against prescribed energy pathways. Indonesia supported the transition in principle while seeking predictable financing. OPEC made the case for fossil fuels on Wednesday.
Seher Raheja of the Centre for Science and Environment in India was blunt about the draft: “It’s kicking the can down the road.” Pooja Dave of Climate Action Network International said: “You made a promise, a commitment, and you are breaking that commitment.” The UN climate chief, Simon Stiell, offered the standard presidency-adjacent optimism: “Yes, geopolitical headwinds are fierce, but an ambitious outcome is within reach.” Chris Bowen, presiding over the negotiations, reminded delegates it is “the first draft, not the final one.”
Separately, on 17 November, Denmark, Luxembourg, Spain and Portugal announced national fossil-fuel phase-out plans, and the Blue Pacific group announced a roadmap.
Limitations
This is a state-of-play report on a negotiation that will have moved by the time it is read. The draft’s exact wording comes from reporting rather than from the text itself, and one secondary outlet’s rendering of a “phase-out” paragraph could not be verified directly. India’s rejection of the electrification pledge is reported but its stated reasoning is not. The date on which Yadav delivered the statement — 17 or 18 November — is not firmly established.
– Kuppuswamy



