Doctors at the All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, say they have performed India’s first open foetal surgery to repair a myelomeningocele, the most severe form of spina bifida. The operation was carried out at 25 weeks of pregnancy, lasted six hours and involved more than 30 clinicians and nurses. Mother and foetus are reported to be stable. The surgeons stress that the procedure is not a cure, but international evidence shows that repair before birth can reduce some of the condition’s most serious complications.
Spina bifida begins in the first month of pregnancy, often before a woman knows she is pregnant. In the most severe form, the spinal cord and its coverings protrude through an opening in the lower back, exposed to the amniotic fluid for the rest of the pregnancy. For decades the only option was surgery after birth. AIIMS Delhi has now brought the alternative, operating on the foetus in the womb, to India.
What was done
According to ANI’s report, first published on 14 November and widely carried on 15 November, the team repaired a lumbosacral myelomeningocele at 25 weeks’ gestation. The operation took place at the AIIMS Neurosciences Centre, lasted about six hours and was performed under an operating microscope with continuous ultrasound monitoring. Planning took more than five weeks and included detailed foetal imaging, non-directive counselling for the family, anaesthetic planning and rehearsal of the operation. The procedure was provided free under the Janani Shishu Suraksha Karyakram, the government scheme for maternal and newborn care.
The team was led by Professor Deepak Gupta of the neurosurgery department, whose head, Professor P.S. Chandra, said: “It is better to nip the problem in the bud.” Maternal-foetal medicine and obstetrics were led by Professors Neena Malhotra and K. Aparna Sharma, with specialists in anaesthesia, plastic surgery, neonatology and radiology. “The safety of both mother and fetus depends on detailed counselling, high-quality anaesthesia, and coordinated surveillance,” Professor Sharma said.
Professor Gupta was careful about expectations: “It is not a cure, and long-term multidisciplinary care remains essential.”
Why operate before birth?
The neural tube, the embryonic structure that becomes the brain and spinal cord, normally closes about four weeks after conception. When the lower end fails to close, the exposed spinal cord can be damaged during the rest of pregnancy by contact with amniotic fluid and by mechanical injury. Many affected babies also develop a hindbrain herniation, known as a Chiari II malformation, and a build-up of fluid in the brain (hydrocephalus) that often requires a permanently implanted shunt.
The rationale for foetal surgery comes largely from the Management of Myelomeningocele Study (MOMS), a randomised trial in the United States reported in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2011. It compared repair before 26 weeks with standard repair after birth. Children who had prenatal repair were much less likely to need a shunt by 12 months: about 40%, against about 82% after postnatal repair. They also had better motor function at 30 months. The trial was stopped early because of the benefit.
The trade-offs
Open foetal surgery is not without cost, and the risks fall mainly on the mother. The operation requires opening the abdomen and the uterus. The same trial found higher rates of preterm birth and of thinning or separation of the uterine scar in women who had prenatal repair. Women who have had open foetal surgery are generally advised to deliver later pregnancies by caesarean section. That is why the AIIMS team emphasised counselling: families must weigh a potential benefit to the child against real risks to the mother and to future pregnancies. (These trial findings are summarised from NSH’s knowledge of the published literature and were not re-verified in this cycle.)
Foetal repair also does not restore nerve function already lost. Many children will still need bladder and bowel management, orthopaedic care and physiotherapy. Professor Gupta’s statement reflects this.
The scale of the problem in India
Neural tube defects are more common in India than in many high-income countries. A systematic review cited in coverage of the AIIMS case gives a pooled prevalence of about 9.5 per 1,000 births; NSH has not independently verified that figure. Much of this burden is preventable. Taking folic acid before conception and in early pregnancy substantially lowers the risk of neural tube defects, and several countries fortify staple foods with folic acid. India’s anaemia-control programme supplies iron and folic acid to women, but coverage before conception, when the neural tube is forming, remains a gap.
What this changes, and what it does not
A single successful operation does not create a service. Foetal surgery depends on early and accurate detection through mid-pregnancy anomaly scans, rapid referral, and a specialised team that can manage both mother and foetus. For now, that capacity exists in very few centres. Mid-pregnancy anomaly scans are also unevenly available across India, particularly in rural districts, so many cases are still detected late or only at birth, when the option of foetal repair has passed. The value of the AIIMS case is that it shows the procedure can be performed in India’s public health system, free to the family, and it offers a model that other tertiary centres could follow with training and protocols.
There are limitations. This is one case, reported by the hospital and the media rather than in a peer-reviewed journal, and the outcome at and after birth is not yet known. The claim to be “India’s first” is AIIMS’s own; NSH has not established whether less invasive foetoscopic repairs have been attempted elsewhere in the country.
What to watch
- The birth outcome and the child’s need for a shunt.
- Whether AIIMS publishes the case and establishes a referral pathway.
- Any national push to improve folic acid use before conception.
– Rashmi Kumari M



